Letter to the editor: Why pick taxes over a plan?

Posted

The question before the Centralia City Council on Nov. 24 is simple: why pick taxes over a plan? Two years ago, Centralia and Chehalis faced the same choice. Chehalis made a plan and is now $2.3 million in the black. Centralia did not, and we are $2 million in the hole. Our problem was never a shortage of taxes. It was a habit of spending and a loss of the fiscal discipline we put in place in 2000.

Chehalis was projecting a $1.4 million deficit every year through 2027. Rather than reach for a new tax, it completed its annexation, budgeted for growth, and turned deficit into surplus, without a business and occupation (B&O) tax.

Centralia’s revenue grew; City staff report tax revenues up as much as 23%. But by staff’s own numbers, costs rose 26%, and the city used its full banked property tax capacity to cover it. Today, we are $2 million short, with less than $700,000 in reserves, and the only options on the table are new taxes.

No amount of new taxes will be enough if spending is not managed. A tax closes this gap once. If spending keeps outpacing revenue, we will be back in two years asking for more.

I appreciate the hard work every councilor has put into this budget. But that is why I support Councilor Tucker Voetberg. A finance committee member and an accountant, he has a plan that balances the budget with no new taxes and no staff cuts, using the money the city already has and restoring discipline. And it does that before counting any of the new revenue already on its way: annexation next July, the state’s annexation sales tax credit, and growing sports tourism. None of that is in the current budget. That is the upside, and it is why we need a planning team of business and community leaders to capture it, so the next two years build a surplus, not another shortfall.

Councilor Voetberg represents the next generation in a true stand of leadership. I have two sons in that generation. We can hand them a place of opportunity, or a tax that tells every employer at Exit 82 that Centralia is a hard place to do business. Opportunity builds a reputation. A tax damages one. And we have the assets to deliver it: a regional sports complex, a historic downtown, a port on I-5 and a location between Seattle and Portland most cities would envy.



Exemptions for small businesses are a maneuver, not a promise. Thresholds drop, carve-outs narrow, and soon everybody pays.

Chehalis fixed its problem. Centralia can fix ours. If we start on day one, with the money we already have and a plan like Chehalis, we will not be here again in two years. It requires work, but this community has done it before. I ask the council to support Councilor Voetberg’s plan, and I ask my neighbors to be there on Nov. 24.

 

Dale Pullin

Centralia