Washington state teen pleads not guilty to five murder charges in adult court

Posted

A teenager charged with five counts of aggravated first-degree murder stemming from a 2024 mass shooting in Fall City pleaded not guilty on Tuesday in adult court.

The arraignment for Andrew Humiston, now 17, came over two years after the killings because his case was just moved from juvenile court to adult court, a process known as a discretionary decline."

Humiston was 15 when he was arrested after the killing of his parents and three of his siblings at their Fall City home. He is charged with five counts of aggravated first-degree murder and one count of attempted murder, all of which he pleaded not guilty to Tuesday.

Those killed were 43-year-old Mark Humiston, 42-year-old Sarah Humiston, and three of their children: Katheryn Humiston, 7; Joshua Humiston, 9; and Benjamin Humiston, 13. The surviving sibling, a girl now age 13, was injured and later told investigators that her brother shot her.

Andrew Humiston was being held Tuesday on no bail, which his attorneys decided to reserve argument about this week. King County Superior Court Judge Veronica Galván said there are constitutional questions regarding the no bail hold "given that he is under the age of 18."

Throughout the decline hearing, Humiston's attorneys painted their client as a socially isolated, abused and mentally ill boy in a fanatically religious family. The father's siblings and parents urged the judge to keep the case in juvenile court.

Galván ruled that the seriousness of the offense, the teen’s rehabilitative prospects and the merit of the evidence mandated trying the case in adult court.



Prosecutors allege that Humiston, early in the morning on Oct. 21, 2024, entered a code into the lockbox where his father’s handgun and a loaded magazine were stored, then shot his father while he was getting ready for work, his siblings while they were still in their pajamas, and his mother while she tried to take cover behind a toilet in her bathroom.

According to charging documents, prosecutors believe Humiston placed the gun in his 13-year-old brother's hand to make it look like a self-inflicted wound, changed his clothes and called 911, speaking in a frightened voice to the operator.

The King County medical examiner’s office determined the 13-year-old was shot in the head from over 2 feet away, and had another wound from a gun that was fired between 6 and 24 inches away, charges say.

The surviving sibling escaped through her bedroom window and ran to a neighbors' house.

Galván set a trial date for January but noted it is "set in sand." It is not uncommon for trial dates to be pushed back repeatedly as attorneys prepare.

"We're not going to wait two more years to go to trial,” Galván said.

© 2026 The Seattle Times. Visit www.seattletimes.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.