Jury awards $935K to fired Sandy interim police chief, finding city violated his free speech

Posted

A federal jury on Friday found that the city of Sandy, its city manager, deputy city manager and former mayor fired interim police chief Sean Lundry in retaliation for exercising his free speech rights and awarded him $935,000 in damages.

The eight-member jury awarded Lundry $850,000 in economic damages, to be paid by the city, two current city employees and a former mayor.

The jury also imposed punitive damages individually: $50,000 against former Mayor Stan Pulliam, $25,000 against City Manager Tyler Deems and $10,000 against Deputy City Manager Jeff Aprati.

Lundry had been serving as Sandy’s interim police chief when he was fired on June 18, 2024. The firing came after he criticized city leadership in a Facebook post and helped organize public records requests seeking information about the city’s selection process for the chief’s job. The public records requests were made after the city had selected an outside candidate for the permanent police chief position.

In a statement Saturday, Lundry’s lawyers Chris K. Heywood and Colin H. Hunter called Lundry “a dedicated public servant of over 20 years who paid an enormous price for speaking out against the City of Sandy.”

They said they were honored “to hold the City and its agents accountable for the violation of Mr. Lundry’s constitutional rights, and the irreparable harm to his career.”

The city’s attorney, Kim E. Hoyt, had countered at trial that Lundry worked to undermine the police department and city after he was passed over for the chief’s job. She argued that his public statements, including social media criticism of city leadership while still interim chief were not constitutionally protected speech.

“The City had an interest in promoting workplace efficiency and avoiding disruption of the Police Department which Plaintiff’s conduct caused through his statements,” Hoyt wrote in a trial brief.

The weeklong federal jury trial before U.S. District Judge Amy M. Baggio centered on the city’s selection process for police chief. The jurors deliberated for about five hours before returning a verdict about 5 p.m. Friday.

Deems, the city manager, had selected Gary Jensen, a Utah police chief from Logan City, as the preferred candidate in early 2024. The city extended Jensen a conditional job offer but later rescinded it after community members raised concerns about his background, including a widely reported allegation that he had offered preferential treatment to Utah State University football players.

The selection of Jensen over Lundry — a local candidate with strong community support — triggered significant public backlash.

At trial, Lundry’s lawyers argued that city leaders conspired to fire him because he and his supporters had filed public records requests with the city and then won an order from the Clackamas County District Attorney’s office requiring the city to release community comment cards submitted to the city following a chief’s candidate forum attended by the three finalists.

City officials, disturbed by the negative community response to their selection of Jensen, were also accused at trial of disparaging Lundry on the city’s and their personal social media pages, as well as in private text messages among themselves.

Former Mayor Pulliam repeatedly testified at trial that he had absolutely no role in the police chief selection process, emphasizing that such decisions rested with the city manager under Sandy’s council-manager form of government.

“Quite frankly, “ Pulliam told jurors, “I’m wondering why I’m here.”

He added: “All these decisions were Mr. Deems. That’s how our city government works … I wasn’t part of the process.”

However, in a prior sworn deposition taken in September 2025, Pulliam acknowledged talking with other city representatives about replacing Lundry as interim chief.



When Lundry’s lawyer Heywood had Pulliam read from portions of that deposition on the witness stand at trial, Pulliam recounted saying of Lundy: “It appeared he was coaching people on public record requests.”

Asked why that was problematic, Pulliam had answered during his deposition, “I just mean he was taking an active role in trying to get information out … and overall, trying to create consternation in the community.” When pressed further in the deposition, Pulliam said it was “more than that,” and referenced Lundry’s comments on social media and negative press coverage.

On the witness stand at trial, Pulliam continued to maintain that he had no involvement in the chief’s selection process. Deems “wasn’t asking my opinion of it,” Pulliam testified.

Yet, when questioned further by Heywood, Pulliam admitted he had personally met with finalist Jensen after a community candidate forum in January 2024, before Jensen returned to Utah.

Pulliam also admitted at trial that he had asked to meet any candidate other than Lundry whom the city manager might select for chief, and that he and Deems met with Jensen before any formal offer was made. When Heywood pressed him — “But you had no input?” — Pulliam replied: “I get to have an opinion.”

Sandy Council President Laurie Smallwood, who also testified, described the 2024 chief selection process as a “mess.” She said Pulliam had urged her to “trust the process,” and shared with her that “Sean was not his guy. He wanted someone else.” She testified that Pulliam had favored Lundry as the next chief until Pulliam had sought to make the city’s police vehicles match the appearance of all other city vehicles, which Lundry opposed.

Smallwood said that during a closed executive council session on Feb. 20, 2024, Pulliam and another council member “wanted to fire Sean and figure out a way to get rid of him” following the public announcement of Jensen’s selection as chief. They cited concerns that Landry was “going to social media,” and that he “wasn’t toeing the line,” Smallwood testified.

Smallwood said Pulliam actively encouraged Lundry’s removal. Three days after the executive session, Deems, the city manager, placed Lundry on paid leave and initiated a criminal investigation based on an anonymous complaint received a month earlier that he had shredded documents. Oregon State Police conducted the criminal investigation and the Clackamas County District Attorney’s office declined to prosecute Lundry. A subsequent independent administrative investigation found no basis for any of the four allegations raised against Lundry.

The day after Lundry was placed on leave, Pulliam sent Smallwood a text message that said: “Feel free to do the right thing and get right,” which she took to suggest that the mayor wanted her to stop supporting Lundry for chief.

Text messages shown to jurors revealed that Deems had written to his deputy in mid-February that he was “so (expletive) done” with the chief’s selection process. In another message, he expressed dismay about social media reaction to his selection of Jensen: “The people who haven’t gotten over their pride are the ones who continue to stir this (expletive) up every freakin’ month.” At trial, Deems said he “regrettably” used foul language.

“I certainly could have chosen other words to use,” he testified.

The jury found in Lundry’s favor on the claim that his First Amendment-protected speech was violated, but it did not find that the city or its officials violated his due process rights or his right to a name-clearing hearing.

Lundry joined the Sandy police department as an officer in 2015, and rose to the rank of lieutenant before he was selected to serve as interim police chief in 2023. He previously was an officer with The Dalles Police Department from 2002 to 2015.

After his firing, he was unable to find another job in law enforcement in Oregon and moved with his wife to Tennessee, where he works as a probation officer, his lawyers said.

The current Sandy police chief is Patrick Huskey, appointed to lead the department in August 2024 after retiring from a 26-year career with Oregon State Police.

©2026 Advance Local Media LLC. Visit oregonlive.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.