Publisher's Note: Centralia doesn't have a revenue problem — it has a spending problem

Posted

Here we go again.

Just two years after the Centralia City Council approved a substantial property tax increase to address a budget shortfall, city hall is back with another financial crisis. And, once again, the solution being considered is to reach deeper into taxpayers' pockets.

This time, it's a proposed business and occupation tax and a square-footage tax on local businesses.

Apparently, the last tax increase wasn't enough.

Before the council goes any further, Centralia taxpayers deserve an explanation, not another warning about services we might lose or another lecture about the difficult decisions elected officials have to make.

Let's look at the numbers.

In 2019, Centralia's general fund collected approximately $12.75 million while spending $10.73 million on operations. That's a surplus of roughly $2 million. The city ended the year with nearly $7 million in cash and investments. Not a bad position to be in. But something changed.

In 2020, revenue dropped to approximately $12.09 million while operating expenses climbed to $11.86 million. In one year, revenue fell by more than $660,000 while spending increased by more than $1.1 million.

By 2022, operating expenses had grown to $12.56 million. Between 2019 and 2022, revenue increased approximately 2.5%, while operating spending jumped 17%. You don't need to be a CPA to see where this was heading.

By July 2023, the city's amended budget anticipated spending approximately $334,000 more than it expected to collect in annual general fund revenue.

The warning signs were there.

Then came October 2024. City officials announced a projected $1.2 million shortfall for the upcoming budget. Sound familiar?

The solution was a substantial property tax increase. Collections that totaled approximately $1.07 million in 2023 were set to reach $2.28 million in 2025. More than double. Various fees and permit charges also increased.

Taxpayers were told these measures were necessary to stabilize the budget. Now, barely two years later, we're right back where we started.

Centralia faces another projected $1.9 million shortfall for 2027-2028. On Nov. 10, the council voted 4-3 to have staff prepare a budget incorporating two new business taxes.

I've spent my career in the private sector and served 18 years on the Chehalis City Council, including two terms as mayor pro tem.

I understand municipal budgets. I understand that inflation, insurance, employee benefits and state mandates create financial pressure. Police protection, infrastructure and other essential services aren't optional.

But I also understand something that seems to get lost in government.

You cannot continually spend beyond your sustainable revenue and expect taxpayers to make up the difference.

There's another troubling part of this story.

The state auditor identified material weaknesses in Centralia's financial reporting controls for 2021 and 2022. In June 2025, S&P Global Ratings downgraded the city's bond rating from AA-minus to A-plus, citing delayed financial reporting and weakened reserves.

Those findings don't establish wrongdoing. But they should raise serious questions about financial oversight.



By March 2026, authorized general fund expenditures exceeded projected revenues by approximately $2.79 million over the biennium. City officials point to insurance, employee compensation, inflation and other obligations.

Fair enough. But were these costs really that difficult to anticipate?

Insurance didn't suddenly become expensive. Employee compensation isn't a surprise. Every business owner has been dealing with inflation for years.

Why weren't the difficult decisions made before another crisis developed?

Which brings me to something that particularly bothers me.

Whenever government wants more money, the first services we hear might be threatened are police, parks, streets and public safety.

Why are essential services always the first things put on the chopping block? It's almost as if taxpayers are being told to accept higher taxes or lose the very services government exists to provide.

I don't accept that choice. I recently heard an elected official describe raising taxes as making a hard decision. I couldn't disagree more.

Raising taxes is the easy decision.

The hard decision is telling department heads the money isn't there. It's reviewing positions, programs and expenditures and determining what taxpayers can actually afford. It's telling people that while a program might be worthwhile, the city simply cannot afford it. That won't make everyone happy. But that's leadership. And that's what voters elect council members to do.

Before asking businesses for another dime, I'd like to know where the additional property tax revenue went. How much was consumed by compensation, benefits, insurance or expanded programs?

What spending reductions have been considered? Which ones were rejected? And why? Those aren't unreasonable questions.

Centralia's businesses are already dealing with higher labor costs, insurance, utilities and inflation. Unlike government, they can't simply vote themselves more revenue.

A business and occupation tax generally applies to gross revenue, not profit. A business can actually lose money and still owe the tax. A square-footage tax adds another burden, particularly for businesses requiring larger facilities.

How exactly does making Centralia more expensive encourage economic development or attract new employers? You cannot tax your way to prosperity while making life more difficult for the businesses that create jobs and generate the revenue your city depends on.

Centralia's financial problems didn't happen overnight. The numbers show spending pressures building for years. The city's business owners deserve more than another tax bill. They deserve accountability and a credible plan to bring spending under control.

Centralia doesn't need another creative way to collect money. It needs elected officials willing to make the hard decisions about how that money is spent.

Until city hall can demonstrate that it has done everything reasonably possible to control spending, I don't believe it has earned the right to ask local businesses for another dime.

•••

Chad Taylor is the publisher of The Chronicle. He and his wife, Coralee, own CT Publishing.