TENINO — Ask any soccer player or coach about penalty kicks, including Toledo coach Horst Malunat, and they will tell you the same thing.
Players can take as many as they can in a practice setting, but when it comes to the pressure of the moment in a game, anything can happen.
No. 3 Toledo didn’t handle the pressure as well as No. 6 Okanogan did on Saturday afternoon in Tenino, as the Riverhawks fell 3-2 (3-1 PKs) to the Bulldogs in the 1B/2B State Quarterfinals.
“I thought we had all the momentum in both of the overtime (halves),” Malunat said. “I didn’t want it to go to PKs. I just had this feeling. But it did, and that’s the way it is.”
Toledo converted on just one of four chances at the spot in the shootout, while Okanogan drilled three brilliant penalties in its four chances.
“No keeper would have saved those,” Malunat said. “Those three goals they scored were impossible. They hit three great ones.”
The fifth and final round of the penalty shootout was unnecessary after Okanogan’s keeper saved Toledo’s fourth shot. After the referees took a second to confirm the shootout scoreline, the final whistle blew, and the Bulldogs raced towards their keeper to celebrate.
A win would have put the Riverhawks into the state semifinals for the first time since 2021. Instead, Toledo finishes one win shy of a state trophy, and Okanogan is moving on to face No. 2 Cle Elum-Roslyn.
“I’m sad, because this is the group that we could have gone a little further with,” Malunat said. “But we did the best we could. They never gave up.”
To force overtime and the penalty shootout, the Riverhawks needed a late spark.
Toledo’s Aspen Cooper opened the scoring in just the fourth minute of the game, but Okanogan’s Olivia Morrison scored twice in the second half to put the Bulldogs ahead 2-1 with around 12 minutes remaining.
Morrison’s first goal came on after a free kick ricocheted to her in the box, and the second came when she went bar-down after winning a footrace to the ball near the top of the 18-yard box.
Cooper responded almost immediately after the second goal, sprinting up the left side of the field and scoring the game-tying goal just two minutes later.
“She put them under pressure the whole time,” Malunat said of his freshman striker.
Over the final 10 minutes of regulation and the 10 minutes of extra time, Toledo maintained possession, including several spells deep in the attacking third, but the Riverhawks weren’t able to generate any more Grade-A scoring chances to get the winner before the shootout.
By the end of the game, the Riverhawks had outshot the Bulldogs 12-5, and Ivana Cabrera had three saves in net. Both teams earned three corners.
It was the final game for Toledo’s five seniors: Cabrera, Peyton Holter, Zaya Norberg, Onica Chase, and Kailea Lairson.
“They were a really good group that did a great job,” Malunat said. “They played together well.”
Malunat said that despite the disappointing finale, he’s hopeful that with time, his seniors and the entire group will be able to look back on this season fondly.
The Riverhawks finish their season 14-4-2, and they won both the Central 2B League title and their first ever District 4 championship.
“You can’t just go ‘Oh, this game says everything about the season or the girls,’” Malunat said. “We’re better than that, and I hope they understand that too … I’m really proud of them. I think the game plan was good, it just didn’t work out on our end.”
Onalaska knocked out by Cle Elum-Roslyn
The Onalaska girls soccer team also lost a state quarterfinal on Saturday, falling to No. 2 Cle Elum-Roslyn 2-0 on the road.
The Loggers finish their season 13-6-1, a mark that includes a second place finish in both league and districts and a state tournament victory over Highland.
Onalaska will graduate Oleana Rimmereid and Kiley Talley.